The 10 Questions That Separate Great Sales Hires from Bad Fits (Most People Skip #7)

WIll Koning Author
by
Last updated on
15 Oct
3
min read
Contents

Similar Posts

No items found.

You are about to apply for another sales role. Your cursor hovers over the "Submit Application" button. The job description looks decent. The company seems legitimate. The salary range is acceptable.

So you click submit.

Three months later, you are sitting in a role that feels completely wrong. The culture suffocates you. The product does not excite you. The leadership style drains your energy. You start updating your resume again, wondering how you ended up here.

This is the pattern I see constantly. Sales professionals apply to dozens of roles without stopping to ask the most important question: What do I actually need to thrive?

The problem is not that you are not good at sales. The problem is that you are treating job applications like a numbers game instead of a strategic decision. You are optimizing for getting hired, not for finding the right fit.

Most candidates I speak with cannot clearly answer basic questions about what they want from their next role. They know what they are running from (toxic culture, bad product, micromanagement) but not what they are running toward.

This approach guarantees you will keep making the same mistakes.

Before you submit another application, take 10 minutes and get brutally honest with yourself about these questions. Your answers will reveal whether a role is worth pursuing or whether you are about to waste everyone's time.

The Framework: 10 Questions That Actually Matter

1. What do I do best? Close, create opportunities, or grow accounts?

Sales is not one skill. It is a collection of very different capabilities, and most salespeople excel at one specific motion.

Closers thrive in high-pressure, short-cycle environments. They love negotiation, handling objections, and getting deals over the line. They get bored in long, consultative processes.

Opportunity creators (SDRs, BDRs) excel at prospecting, pattern recognition, and opening doors. They love the hunt but often struggle with the patience required for complex deal cycles.

Account growers shine in expansion, upsell, and relationship-building. They prefer working with existing customers over cold prospecting.

If you are a natural closer applying for a strategic account management role focused on relationship nurturing, you will be miserable. If you are an account grower joining a pure new business hunter role, you will struggle.

Action step: Look at your last three career highlights. What motion were you executing? That is your natural strength. Apply for roles that need exactly that.

2. Who do I want to sell to? HR, Finance, Ops, or Marketing?

The persona you sell into shapes your entire day.

Selling to HR means navigating compliance, change management, and people-first concerns. Selling to Finance requires ROI precision, risk mitigation, and cost justification. Selling to Operations focuses on efficiency, process improvement, and implementation. Selling to Marketing emphasizes creativity, differentiation, and brand impact.

These are fundamentally different conversations requiring different skill sets and temperaments.

I have seen brilliant sellers fail because they were selling to personas they found boring or frustrating. One seller I worked with crushed it selling to marketing teams but floundered when moved to finance-focused deals. The skills did not translate because the mindset of the buyers was completely different.

Action step: Write down which buyer personas energize you and which drain you. Then filter roles based on their primary stakeholder. If a company's ICP is CFOs and you hate financial conversations, do not apply.

3. What industry do I want to sell into?

Industry matters more than most people realize.

Selling into hospitality means understanding operational constraints, seasonality, and thin margins. Property/real estate involves long cycles, relationship-heavy deals, and market timing. HR Tech requires fluency in compliance, employee experience, and change management. SaaS demands technical credibility and consultative selling.

The wrong industry will bore you to death, no matter how good the company is.

I have coached sellers who moved from fast-moving SaaS into heavily regulated industries and were shocked by the pace. Others went from transactional hospitality sales into complex enterprise property deals and felt lost.

Action step: Identify which industries genuinely interest you. If you cannot get excited about the problems your prospects face, you will never sell with conviction.

4. What size of organization do I want to sell to? SME, Mid-Market, or Enterprise?

Deal size determines everything: cycle length, stakeholder complexity, quota structure, and day-to-day rhythm.

SME (small and medium enterprise) selling is fast-paced, transactional, and volume-driven. You might close 10-20 deals per quarter. Decision-makers are accessible but budgets are tight.

Mid-market offers balance: longer cycles than SME, more strategic, but not the bureaucracy of enterprise. You are typically closing 5-10 deals per quarter with moderate complexity.

Enterprise means complex, multi-stakeholder deals taking 6-18 months. You might close 1-3 deals per year, but each deal is transformational. It requires political savvy, patience, and resilience.

If you thrive on momentum and quick wins, enterprise selling will frustrate you. If you love deep strategy and relationship-building, SME transactional sales will bore you.

Action step: Reflect on past roles. Which deal size and cycle length made you feel most alive? Apply only to roles matching that profile.

5. What size of organization do I want to join? Start-up, scale-up, or global player?

Company stage shapes your entire experience.

Start-ups (0-50 people) offer equity upside, ambiguity, and broad responsibility. You will wear many hats, build process from scratch, and face constant change. Compensation is often lower base with higher risk/reward through equity.

Scale-ups (50-500 people) provide structure with growth. You have some process, a leadership team, and real momentum. Compensation is competitive, and there is still room to make an impact.

Global players (500+ people) offer stability, brand recognition, and established playbooks. You have resources, support, and structure. Compensation is typically highest in base salary but lowest in equity upside.

The wrong choice here causes more career dissatisfaction than almost anything else. Entrepreneurial sellers joining big corporates feel suffocated. Process-oriented sellers joining chaotic start-ups feel lost.

At meritt, we often help candidates think through this tradeoff. Many sellers think they want the start-up experience until they realize they actually need structure, coaching, and predictability.

Action step: Be honest about your risk tolerance, need for structure, and career stage. If you have a mortgage and kids, the start-up equity gamble might not be wise. If you are early career and crave learning, the corporate role might stall your growth.

6. What set-up gets the best out of me? Remote, hybrid, or full-time office?

This is not just about preference. It is about performance.

Some sellers thrive in remote environments: self-directed, comfortable with async communication, and energized by autonomy. Others need the office for energy, collaboration, and structure. Many prefer hybrid as a middle ground.

The wrong setup will kill your productivity and happiness.

I have seen remote-first sellers join office-heavy cultures and feel micromanaged. I have seen collaborative sellers go fully remote and feel isolated, losing motivation.

Action step: Reflect on where you have performed best historically. If you are not sure, ask yourself: do I energize around people or do I recharge alone? Your honest answer reveals your ideal setup.

7. What kind of culture do I thrive in?

This is the question most people skip, and it is the one that determines whether you stay or quit within 12 months.

Do you thrive in fast-paced, high-pressure environments where targets are aggressive and competition is celebrated? Or do you prefer collaborative, supportive cultures where teamwork matters more than individual glory? Do you need target-driven clarity or do you want autonomy and flexibility?

Culture mismatch is the number one cause of early attrition in sales roles. You can tolerate a mediocre product or a less-than-perfect territory, but you cannot tolerate a culture that conflicts with your values.

Action step: Write down the cultural attributes of the best role you ever had. Then write down the attributes of the worst. Use these as your filter. During interviews, ask questions that expose culture: How do you celebrate wins? How do you handle missed targets? How do decisions get made?

8. What type of leadership brings out my best?

Sales leadership styles vary wildly, and the wrong manager will destroy your performance.

Some sellers need hands-on coaching: frequent check-ins, feedback loops, and structured development. Others need autonomy: clear targets, trust, and space to operate.

Micromanagers suffocate independent sellers. Absent managers leave coaching-hungry sellers adrift.

The brutal truth is that your manager matters more than the company. A great manager in a mediocre company beats a mediocre manager in a great company every time.

Action step: In interviews, ask direct questions about management style: How often do you meet with your team? How do you coach? What does success look like in the first 90 days? The answers will reveal whether this leader will bring out your best or worst.

9. What do I actually want from my next move?

This is the question that requires the most honesty.

Are you chasing longevity (staying somewhere 3-5 years to build deep expertise)? Are you focused on skill development (learning a new motion, industry, or stakeholder)? Do you want new challenges that stretch you? Or are you seeking financial upside through commission or equity?

Most people want all of these, but you cannot optimize for everything. You have to choose your priority.

If you want skill development, you might accept a lower base salary for better coaching. If you want financial upside, you might tolerate a less-than-perfect culture for massive commission potential.

At meritt, we push candidates to get clear on this before we introduce them to roles. When you know what you are optimizing for, every decision becomes easier.

Action step: Rank these four goals in order of importance: longevity, development, challenge, financial upside. Your ranking reveals which roles to pursue.

10. Why did not my previous move(s) work out? And how do I avoid repeating it?

The most important question is the one no one wants to answer.

If your last role did not work out, there is a reason. Maybe you joined for the wrong reasons (brand name, salary, pressure from others). Maybe you ignored red flags during the interview process. Maybe you misunderstood the role or overestimated your fit.

Whatever the reason, if you do not identify it, you will repeat it.

I have coached sellers who have made the same mistake three times: joining high-pressure, quota-driven cultures when they actually thrive in collaborative, relationship-focused environments. They keep thinking "this time will be different," but it never is because they have not addressed the root cause.

Action step: Write down why your last 1-2 roles did not work out. Be brutally honest. Then identify the pattern. What were you ignoring? What were you hoping would change? Use this insight as a filter for your next move.

How to Use These Answers

Once you have answered these questions, you have a filter. Every role you consider should be evaluated against this framework.

Before applying, ask yourself: Does this role match my answers to these 10 questions?

If the answer is no to more than 3 questions, do not apply. You are wasting your time and theirs.

If the answer is yes to 8 or more, that is a role worth pursuing with intention.

During interviews, use these answers to ask better questions. Instead of generic questions like "what is the culture like?", ask specific questions based on your framework: "I thrive in collaborative environments where teamwork is valued over individual competition. Can you share an example of how your team celebrates wins together?"

This approach shows you are strategic, self-aware, and serious about fit, not just desperate for any offer.

The Outcome: Better Roles, Faster Success, Longer Tenure

Here is what happens when you apply this framework:

You apply to fewer roles but get better responses because your applications are targeted and intentional. You interview with clarity because you know exactly what you are looking for. You make better decisions because you are evaluating fit, not just accepting the first offer.

Most importantly, you land in roles where you actually thrive. You hit quota faster, stay longer, and build momentum instead of constantly restarting.

This is exactly the kind of strategic thinking we look for at meritt when we assess candidates. We evaluate curiosity, coachability, grit, and communication because we know these traits predict success far better than resume keywords. But we also care deeply about fit. We want candidates in roles where they will thrive, not just survive.

If you are serious about your next sales move, take 10 minutes right now and answer these questions honestly. Write them down. Use them as your filter.

Your career will thank you.

FAQs

What questions should I ask myself before applying for a sales job?
Before applying, clarify what you do best (closing, creating opportunities, or growing accounts), who you want to sell to (which buyer personas), what industry excites you, and what company size and stage match your work style. Also consider your ideal work setup (remote, hybrid, office), the culture you thrive in, and what you actually want from your next move (skill development, longevity, financial upside, or new challenges). Finally, identify why previous roles did not work out so you avoid repeating mistakes. These answers create a filter that helps you apply strategically instead of desperately.
How do I know if a sales role is right for me?
Evaluate the role against your strengths and preferences. If you are a natural closer, avoid roles focused on account management and relationship nurturing. If you hate financial conversations, do not sell to CFOs. Consider whether the deal size (SME, mid-market, enterprise) matches your preferred pace and cycle length. Assess company stage (start-up, scale-up, global player) against your need for structure versus autonomy. A role is right when it aligns with your natural strengths, energizes rather than drains you, and matches your career priorities for this specific move.
What are the biggest mistakes people make when choosing sales jobs?
The biggest mistake is treating job applications like a numbers game instead of a strategic decision. People apply everywhere without clarity on what they need to thrive, focusing on getting hired rather than finding the right fit. They ignore culture misalignment, accept roles that do not match their natural strengths, and fail to learn from previous bad fits. Many optimize for salary or brand name while overlooking deal size, buyer personas, and leadership style. This results in accepting offers for roles where they will struggle, leading to early attrition and career restarts.
How important is company culture when choosing a sales role?
Culture is the number one factor determining whether you stay or quit within 12 months. You can tolerate a mediocre product or less-than-perfect territory, but you cannot thrive in a culture that conflicts with your values and work style. Some sellers need fast-paced, competitive environments while others thrive in collaborative, supportive cultures. Culture mismatch causes more early attrition than any other factor. During interviews, ask specific questions that expose culture: how wins are celebrated, how missed targets are handled, and how decisions get made. Your manager's leadership style matters more than the company brand.

Ready to hire top talent faster, without the hassle?

Ready to Level Up?

Apply for jobs and complete your video introduction, where you can show your personality and communication skills upfront.

You'll get instant AI-powered coaching feedback to help you present your best
self and stand out from other candidates.